Photography Life

PL provides various digital photography news, reviews, articles, tips, tutorials and guides to photographers of all levels

  • Reviews
    • Camera Reviews
    • Lens Reviews
  • Learn
  • About Us
  • Forum
  • Search
Home → Cameras and Lenses

Should You Switch from DSLR to Mirrorless?

A different perspective on the typical DSLR vs mirrorless articles

By Spencer Cox 219 Comments
Last Updated On February 11, 2023

Abstract Photography
NIKON D800E + 70-200mm f/4 @ 140mm, ISO 500, 1/500, f/5.6

By now, Nikon has completely switched focus from DSLRs to mirrorless with a rapidly growing set of lenses. Canon has made exactly the same transition. Except Pentax, camera companies have moved on from DSLRs to mirrorless. Should you?

I’d like to start by saying that this is not a DSLR vs mirrorless article. Like everyone else, we’ve already written one of those, and truth be told, mirrorless won that debate a while ago. Mirrorless cameras now have countless benefits and vanishingly few drawbacks over DSLRs, at least in specifications and feature sets. Mirrorless is the camera industry, as we’ve said for years now.

However, there’s still a massive audience of photographers who shoot with DSLRs. Maybe that includes you. It certainly includes a few of the writers at Photography Life.

If you’re still shooting with a DSLR, chances are high that you’ve thought about the pros and cons of moving to mirrorless, and maybe you’re not sure about the right path. Is it a good idea to make the leap?

By now, no doubt, you understand the tradeoffs and the cost of switching. So, instead of talking about things like lens lineups or feature sets in this article, I’d like to delve into some of the more nuanced qualities of changing camera systems – the creative differences and reasons why you don’t always need to chase the hype train.

Image Quality; Quality Images

There is no inherent difference between DSLRs and mirrorless cameras in image quality. That said, almost all the R&D money from camera makers is going into mirrorless cameras, so today’s cutting-edge performance is increasingly found on the mirrorless side of things. These come in all forms, including high ISO performance, pixel count, better video features, and dynamic range.

There also is an inherent advantage in designing lenses for mirrorless cameras, thanks to the shorter flange distance and larger diameter mounts of most mirrorless systems. Yet I’ve heard a sentiment like this from some photographers: “I don’t know why, but DSLR photos look better to me.”

Tamron-17-35mm-f2-8-4-21
NIKON D780 + Tamron 17-35mm f/2.8-4E @ 25mm, ISO 100, 1/400, f/9.0

On one hand, empirically, DSLR photos aren’t any better. Heck, if you shoot a DSLR in live view – or, say, rip out the mirror – you’re already effectively shooting with a mirrorless camera. I guarantee there’s not a person reading this article who can reliably tell the difference between a DSLR photo and a mirrorless photo in a side-by-side test (given the same sensor, like the Nikon D780 vs Z6 II).

But, somehow, the “DSLR photos look better” sentiment feels truer than it should, especially to some photographers and DSLR holdouts. When I squint, I can see it too: that perhaps the average quality of photos has gone down in the mirrorless age, even looking at work from the same photographers.

2016 Great Sand Dunes Black and White
NIKON D800E + 70-200mm f/4 @ 86mm, ISO 100, 1/10, f/16.0

If that’s true, it has nothing to do with sensor differences. Any difference would be the result of process. It’s the same reason why I’ve never once taken a decent photo with my phone, even though many other photographers have. Quite simply, I don’t put in the right effort, since I use my phone as a tool for quick snapshots and nothing else.

Today’s mirrorless cameras are more competent than DSLRs. They are also easier to carry along and use in a mobile workflow. They incentivize faster, more image production and sharing. 11 FPS used to be flagship-level speed in the DSLR world, and now, when an entry-level mirrorless camera boasts that number, I call the camera uninspiring.

I was struck by a reader’s comment on one of Libor’s recent articles: “You asked: How often do I take out my camera? Answer: For me it has been months. I have a backlog of 50K unprocessed NEFs to go through; plus thousands of inherited photos from a dead relative. Frankly I’m overwhelmed by the backlog.”

The glut is real. It stops us from going out and practicing photography; it shuts us down. Or, if it doesn’t shut us down, it leads us to give each photo less attention than it deserves, since we’re working with so many photos in total.

Spencer-Cox-Castle
NIKON D800E + 24mm f/1.4 @ 24mm, ISO 100, 0.6 seconds, f/16.0

DSLRs can lead to this problem, too, but I doubt I’m alone in realizing that I take more photos with mirrorless on a typical outing than I did with a DSLR. I pull my mirrorless camera out more often in the first place, since it’s less hassle – and each time I do, I take more photos than I would before.

In other words, the “cost of a photo” is even lower with mirrorless than it was with DSLRs. The Nikon Z9 doesn’t even have a mechanical shutter, and so you don’t have to worry about the camera failing at several hundred thousand shots.

This isn’t a complaint, for the most part. I’m thrilled that photography is more affordable and accessible these days; experimentation is also more feasible, and difficult subjects like birds in flight are easier to capture than ever before.

Tokina 100mm Macro Lens Adapted to Nikon Z7 with FTZ Adapter
NIKON Z 7 + 100mm f/2.8 @ 100mm, ISO 125, 1/640, f/6.3

But it’s a different experience of photography. In a way, a speed bump has been removed. With mirrorless, if you don’t consciously think about slowing down and taking the best possible photo, it’s easier to take “happenstance” pictures – and a lot of them. It’s also easy to spend insufficient time post-processing your better photographs, since you have more ground to cover and always more photos to process.

That’s why, even though the image quality of mirrorless matches or exceeds that of DSLRs, the quality of an image may not. I don’t think this should scare you away from switching; in the right hands, the better technology of mirrorless cameras can allow you to broaden and maybe even improve your work. However, better photos aren’t inevitable just because your gear is newer or has better specs.

Nikon Z7 Sample Photo of Lightning
NIKON Z 7 + NIKKOR Z 14-30mm f/4 S @ 18.5mm, ISO 64, 20 seconds, f/5.0

The Experience of Photography

Do you remember those viral teasers for the Nikon Df before it was officially announced? A lone landscape photographer in the middle of who knows where, Scotland maybe, at peace as he took a photo through the camera’s viewfinder. “Pure photography,” “No clutter, no distractions” – man did those teasers draw attention. Photographers speculated that the Df wouldn’t have a rear LCD, or that it would use dials for everything and eliminate the menu. I don’t think I’ve ever refreshed Nikon Rumors so often.

The Df’s eventual release didn’t meet those lofty expectations, but that’s beside the point. What Nikon had touched on, maybe without realizing it, was the importance of the experience of photography.

Leica is onto something here with their marketing, too. It’s not just image quality or features that matter in a camera. There’s also the spark that makes you want to pick up the camera in the first place and really look forward to taking pictures.

Classic Landscape Photo at Sunset
NIKON Z 7 + NIKKOR Z 14-30mm f/4 S @ 14mm, ISO 64, 8 seconds, f/13.0

I’m not saying that the only possible source of the “spark” is the camera itself – or that a DSLR has that spark, and mirrorless doesn’t. I know plenty of mirrorless photographers who feel more enthusiastic about photography than they ever did with a DSLR, because now they look forward to taking their lightweight gear places they would never go with a bulkier kit.

But for some photographers, “bringing out the big camera” and “taking it slow” are part of their process of photography. I know I’m like that, maybe even too much. If you’ve read Photography Life regularly, you probably know that I’ve been using large and ultra-large format cameras for most of my recent landscape photography. I’m often using these cameras instead of digital, for reasons that are only tangentially related to image quality. The main reason is that I’ve found a process I adore, that makes me excited to take pictures again.

Mount Bierdstadt Afternoon 4x5 Portra 160
Chamonix 4×5, Nikkor 90mm f/8 @ f/22, 1/60 second. Kodak Portra 160. No filters, some rear tilt.

There’s a rarely-spoken impulse behind most discussions about camera equipment: that the ultimate goal is to get the lightest possible kit that excels at what you photograph. That’s a reasonable goal to aim for, and it’s something that mirrorless does well. But it’s not the only decent direction you can take as a photographer.

Sometimes, it’s better to aim for a process that you enjoy, even at the expense of the camera’s weight, features, or speed. And there’s no denying that the process is different between shooting with a mirrorless camera compared to a DSLR. There’s the difference in the viewfinder, for one, and there’s also the difference in the time and effort it takes to use the camera (with less effort not always being a more enjoyable experience).

If you’ve found your rhythm as a DSLR photographer, I think switching to mirrorless may be wrong for you. To gain a lighter bag and a set of features you’ll rarely use, is it worth giving up that spark? Surely not. To many photographers, the “experience of photography” makes a bigger difference to the quality of their photos than the camera’s feature set, because it’s a more direct factor in how much they enjoy taking pictures, and how often they do so.

Focus in Photography
NIKON D800E + 105mm f/2.8 @ 105mm, ISO 200, 1/320, f/5.6

Conclusion and Recommendations

Mirrorless cameras are the overwhelming present. The only new DSLRs will come from Pentax if Ricoh finds the market big enough to keep making them. If you’re intent on getting a new and improved camera, or you need to replace your old camera, mirrorless is the way to go these days.

But this article is not targeted at photographers who constantly need the newest specs in the world for their work – most of whom have switched to mirrorless already. Instead, it’s targeted at photographers who use a DSLR at the moment, see all sorts of headlines about mirrorless features, and wonder if it’s time to overhaul a DSLR kit that they’re broadly happy with. My answer is no.

If you still shoot with a DSLR and enjoy it, you don’t need to buy into the hype and switch. You probably do need to accept that DSLR development won’t go much further in the future, but that’s not so bad if it’s already developed enough for your needs.

If you switch to mirrorless, your “quality of images” isn’t guaranteed to improve at all, even if the camera has better features. I say you should find a process that works for you, stick with it, and not worry so much about gear. That’s the easiest way to jump off the advertising/hype train and focus your attention on actual photography.

What is landscape photography
NIKON D800E + 70-200mm f/4 @ 70mm, ISO 100, 6 seconds

What if you’ve already switched to mirrorless, and you’re just reading this article for fun? Good on you. I suspect you switched for a reason, and for most of you, the high performance of today’s mirrorless cameras has probably exceeded your expectations.

It did for me. I adore my mirrorless + large format film kit for the flexibility, image quality, and process I’m getting these days. But at the same time, I’ve had to be mindful of slowing down and thinking through my photos so that I don’t take too many smartphone-style snapshots with my Z7.

Comet Neowise above a Lake
NIKON Z 7 + NIKKOR Z 20mm f/1.8 S @ 20mm, ISO 3200, 15 seconds, f/1.8

In the comments, I’d like to hear from you if you still shoot with a DSLR. Are you feeling left behind with all the mirrorless content online these days? Or, is “jumping off the hype train” giving you more time to go out and shoot, and be satisfied with the gear you already have? I’m sure the cost of switching plays a role for many photographers, but hardly all of them; the DSLR is still the tool of choice for many professionals and others. If that includes you, I hope this article gave you a better sense of when it might be time to switch, and when it’s time to stay.


I expected this article to be somewhat popular, because gear discussions and mirrorless vs DSLR in particular usually are! Even so, the number of comments has outpaced my expectations. I can’t respond to every comment I got this time, but I’m reading all of them and am grateful for the interesting and thoughtful responses so far. The dozens of replies I wrote will be easiest to see by sorting the comments by “Oldest” instead of “Newest” below. Thank you! -Spencer

Related Articles

  • Sony A7R II Front
    What is a Mirrorless Camera?
  • Canon 7D
    Where to Buy a Camera
  • Fujifilm X-T20
    Mirrorless Camera Comparison
  • SLR Cross Section
    What is a DSLR (Digital SLR) Camera?
  • mirrorless_VS_DSLR
    DSLR vs Mirrorless Cameras
  • downsize 1
    When People Downsize Their Camera Gear
Disclosures, Terms and Conditions and Support Options
Filed Under: Cameras and Lenses Tagged With: DSLR, DSLR Camera, Essays, Mirrorless, Mirrorless Camera

About Spencer Cox

I'm Spencer Cox, a landscape photographer based in Colorado. I started writing for Photography Life almost ten years ago, and now I run the website in collaboration with Nasim. I've used nearly every digital camera system under the sun, but for my personal work, I love the slow-paced nature of large format film. You can see more at my personal website and my Instagram page.

guest

guest

219 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
rayven
rayven
November 17, 2023 12:06 am

wow — brilliant article. Gets right to the heart of my dilemma. Thank you for your insightful article. It was truly refreshing

0
Reply
Suhail and my K2
Suhail and my K2
November 8, 2023 1:56 pm

British photographer and vlogger James Popsys advised his followers on youtube channel that instead of spending thousands of dollars into new equipment, one should spend the same money traveling and focus on photography with his/her existing camera gear. I am fairly invested in Pentax system and have decided to do exactly that.

0
Reply
Charlie
Charlie
October 24, 2023 7:49 am

Sorry – mirrorless cameras will have to do something pretty special for me to reinvest thousands upon thousands to repurchase a kit – despite Nikon’s hope. And to be perfectly honest, I feel camera bodies, like my D850, already take the most amazing photos, and there are no “advanced features” that can be hyped to overcome the simplicity of taking a nice photo.

0
Reply
Jerry E.
Jerry E.
August 19, 2023 8:38 pm

Thanks for this excellent article. Your comments about the experience of the photographer resonated strongly with me. Starting my serious photography with a Canon FTb and some prime lenses, I noticed that my photos weren’t as good when I used a zoom. I think that the joy of the lens distracted me. It took me a while to adapt to autofocus lenses. Like your comment about phone cameras, I don’t think I am nearly as good with a point and shoot camera, as with my DSLR. I’d like a mirrorless camera, so that I could use my two f/1.2 Canon FD lenses. Given that I’m a septuagenarian, I may ride my current horse as long as it goes – see who lasts longer. My equipment is already better than the photographer who uses it. Thanks again.

2
Reply
Allen D Lange
Allen D Lange
July 24, 2023 12:53 pm

I Liked Your Article I Thought About Switching To Mirrorless But my d-850 Is A Great Dslr and I own about 25 Lenses and it just seems too high of a cost and the lens adapter i heard wasn’t very good.

1
Reply
Quazi Sanjeed
Quazi Sanjeed
June 24, 2023 8:37 am

I read your article with interest. First, let me introduce myself. My name is DSLR Forever. A hobbyist photographer shooting landscape, street photos, lifestyle and wildlife. Use Canon gears and native lenses. My present arsenal can easily support my passion for at least ten years from now. I love shooting without feeling the obligation to be excellent at it.

I have been following the mirrorless hype since the beginning and it didn’t appeal to me or convince me for an expensive switch. Therefore, these days I don’t pay attention to new releases instead, concentrate on my photography. I’m fully convinced that my photographs won’t be any inferior to mirrorless outputs. Moreover, the OVF advantage of real-time view at the speed of light and battery-life are important decisive factors for me.

As per my observations, many present hobbyist mirrorless shooters switched mainly because this is the current fashion. And in this process sustained an unnecessary financial blow.

At the end of the day, when a common admirer appreciates an image; he/she never asks which gear was used to create it.

3
Reply
Robert
Robert
June 20, 2023 2:43 am

Very enjoyable post. I use a D500 with Sigma 300mm f2.8 and a D4 with 80-200 f2.8 for sports . Over the years I have tried to update bodies but the cost of switching to mirrorless is frightening. I have used my songs Sony mirrorless and had good results but no better than what I take. I think I will wait on prices dropping in the second hand market before switching.

0
Reply
Bas Veerkamp
Bas Veerkamp
June 17, 2023 11:31 pm

Thankyou Spencer for this article.

Iam yet stil on the DSLR FX D800 and did have had a lot of experience from the analogue period FM2 F801s and now facing the same to go too Mirrorles.

But in many ways the camera is irrelevant because a lot it hase to do with the joy of know what you do aperture iso lenses and time too take the richt time and place, and have joy.

So youre article helped me too look forward but keep fun in doing what we do.

Greetings Bas ;)

0
Reply
Joe B.
Joe B.
May 21, 2023 11:31 pm

Thank you for writing this article. I was on the fence regarding switching to mirrorless or not. I love my DSLR and am enjoying taking pictures with it. Plus, I have a lot invested in lenses. So, until I am forced into buying new gear, I will stick with what I’ve got.
Thank you for helping me decide!

0
Reply
Anthony
Anthony
May 14, 2023 10:39 pm

Thanks for the article! I’m a pro photographer of 20+ years in Sydney Australia, I started modestly with an F90X as a young pup 19 year old, then onto Canon with a 1D N, 1D MII, and back to Nikon with a D200, D700, D4s, D810 and D850. As you can imagine I’ve collected quite a few F mount lenses over the years….. A whole bunch of Nikon and also a good amount of the lovely Sigma range. Now the Z8 has been announced I’m very tempted to start my transition along with the F lens adaptor. I know it’s not going to change my work in many ways, maybe a few small tech advantages to help my job become a little simpler but it’s very costly to swap my whole system for Z lenses at one time. Do I sell the D850 while it’s still worth something and dive into the Z8 with an adaptor for my current lenses and slowly add some Z lines as time goes on or do I beat my D810 into the ground (Which is still powering on after 400,000 clicks and savour every last frame out of the beautiful D850?? Hmmmm it’s such a tough decision….

0
Reply

Learn

  • Beginner Photography
  • Landscape Photography
  • Wildlife Photography
  • Portraiture
  • Post-Processing
  • Advanced Tutorials

Reviews

  • Camera Reviews
  • Lens Reviews
  • Other Gear Reviews
  • Best Cameras and Lenses

Photography Tutorials

Photography Basics
Landscape Photography
Wildlife Photography
Macro Photography
Composition & Creativity
Black & White Photography
Night Sky Photography
Portrait Photography
Street Photography
Photography Videos

Unique Gift Ideas

Best Gifts for Photographers

Subscribe via Email

If you like our content, you can subscribe to our newsletter to receive weekly email updates using the link below:

Subscribe to our newsletter

Site Menu

  • About Us
  • Beginner Photography
  • Lens Database
  • Lens Index
  • Photo Spots
  • Search
  • Forum

Reviews

  • Reviews Archive
  • Camera Reviews
  • Lens Reviews
  • Other Gear Reviews

More

  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe
  • Workshops
  • Support Us
  • Submit Content

Copyright © 2023 · Photography Life

You are going to send email to

Move Comment