Photography Life

PL provides various digital photography news, reviews, articles, tips, tutorials and guides to photographers of all levels

  • Lens Reviews
  • Camera Reviews
  • Tutorials
  • Compare Cameras
  • Forum
    • Sign Up
    • Login
  • About
  • Search
Home → Videography

Sennheiser, AT and Rode Shotgun Microphone Comparison

By Nasim Mansurov 15 Comments
Last Updated On October 28, 2020

John Bosley and I have been actively working on producing our second Level 1: Post-Processing Basics video and we have decided to look into getting a shotgun microphone for the studio environment. While our lavalier microphones have been working great for the most part, they tend to collect ambient noise quite a bit, especially when the subject moves or accidentally touches the microphone. Additionally, lavalier mikes can be painful to deal when there is a lot of interference, particularly in a busy urban environment. When shooting in San Francisco, we experienced some sort of interference practically in every channel, which made it difficult to shoot (and that’s considering that we had two different transmitters at completely different radio frequency ranges). So it was time to look for a different solution that gives us good quality sound without the problems of the lavalier microphones. We decided to evaluate a number of popular shotgun microphones and we came up with the following list: Sennheiser MKE 600, Audio Technica AT897, Rode NTG2 and Rode NTG3. While the first three are in the same price range (around $300) and therefore can be considered direct competitors, the Rode NTG3 was a higher-end unit priced at around $700. The big question was – which of the four microphones would win us over? Take a look at our video below:

As you can see, we ended up choosing the Sennheiser MKE 600 for our needs, based on the following:

  • The Sennheiser MKE 600 has superb sound recording capabilities, with excellent audio recording levels. While both the AT897 and the NTG2 are also battery-powered, they seem to draw much less power, resulting in rather low audio output. Even with our audio sensitivity level set to the maximum output (100) on the Zoom H4n recording device, we could not reach the desired recording levels. This meant that the audio had to be increased in post, which is not a good option, since increasing audio levels in post typically increases ambient noise. While drawing more battery power surely decreases the number of hours the microphone can be used for on a single battery, the specs say that the unit will still last over 150 hours, which is way more than what we need in the field.
  • Out of the three battery-powered units, the Sennheiser MKE 600 was the only unit that offered an On/Off switch. So the AT897 and the NTG2 constantly draw battery power whether you are using them or not, whereas you can cut it off on the MKE 600. I don’t understand why the other two failed to implement such a simple feature – it is easier to turn the unit off, rather than fiddle with the battery removal process on the field.
  • The Sennheiser MKE 600 is smaller and lighter compared to the Audio Technica AT897 and the Rode NTG2.
  • We have been heavily relying on the Sennheiser EW112 Wireless solution for our audio needs, which works amazingly well in most situations and it makes sense to continue to work with the brand we trust and rely on.

While the most expensive Rode NTG3 did produce very clear and pleasant sound, the fact that it requires external power was a deal breaker for us, since replenishing a single AA battery is much easier than lugging external battery packs with us in the field.

If you are into video production and you are looking for a reliable shotgun microphone, take a closer look at the Sennheiser MKE 600 – that’s what we ended up purchasing for our needs.

Looking for even more exclusive content?

On Photography Life, you already get world-class articles with no advertising every day for free. As a Member, you'll get even more:

Silver ($5/mo)
  • Exclusive articles
  • Monthly Q&A chat
  • Early lens test results
  • "Creative Landscape Photography" eBook
Gold ($12/mo)
  • All that, PLUS:
  • Online workshops
  • Monthly photo critiques
  • Vote on our next lens reviews
 
Click Here to Join Today
 

Related Articles

  • Telephoto Lens Focal Length Comparison
    Telephoto Lens Focal Length Comparison
  • Fujifilm X-T20
    Mirrorless Camera Comparison
  • Nikon D300 vs D90 High ISO Noise Comparison
    Nikon D300 vs D90 High ISO Noise Comparison
  • Nikon D4s vs D4
    Nikon D4s vs D4 High ISO Comparison
  • Nikon DSLR Buffer Capacity Comparison
    Nikon DSLR Buffer Capacity Comparison
  • Nikon D610 vs D800E vs Df vs D4 vs D4s
    Nikon High ISO Comparison using D600, D800E, Df, D4 and D4s
Disclosures, Terms and Conditions and Support Options
Filed Under: Videography Tagged With: Audio Technica, Microphone, Rode, Sennheiser, Shotgun Microphone, Video, Videography

About Nasim Mansurov

Nasim Mansurov is the author and founder of Photography Life, based out of Denver, Colorado. He is recognized as one of the leading educators in the photography industry, conducting workshops, producing educational videos and frequently writing content for Photography Life. You can follow him on Instagram and Facebook. Read more about Nasim here.

guest

guest

15 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Pat Hegarty
Pat Hegarty
February 15, 2021 11:54 am

Hi, I have the Sennheiser Mke 600 which I use for film audio. Works a treat even when placed (In Theory) too far from the actors, especially in outdoor shoots. I intend to purchase a second as I’ve some 2 person interviews to shoot in the future.

0
Reply
Jon
Jon
May 19, 2016 8:47 am

Could you let me know why you didn’t look at the ntg4+, the comparable mic from rode

0
Reply
Greg
Greg
Reply to  Jon
November 17, 2016 4:58 pm

Wondering the same?..

0
Reply
andrew
andrew
May 19, 2016 5:18 am

Hi Nasim and John
I agree with Ludwig Keck in 3.1.1, in that your positioning is not ideal.
Any off-axis sound will sound weird, plus have the channels reversed if extreme.
Also the lapel (lavalier) mic should point away from the talent, i.e. pointing down and this way it’ll better balance the variation when the talent moves head or fiddles with camera. The lapel (lavalier) can also be off-talent (on the desk but close) as its omni-directional.
Phantom power will give a stronger signal.
Your video proved nothing other than your preference, and I was hoping for some insight.

0
Reply
Nasim Mansurov
Nasim Mansurov
Author
Reply to  andrew
May 19, 2016 9:05 am

Andrew, thank you for your feedback! Please see my response to Ludwig – hopefully it clarifies exactly why we setup the mike the way we did.

As for the lapel sound, we have been using it in three different arrangements: mike facing upwards, mike being inside the shirt of the subject and mike facing down. While the latter sounded pretty good, the only way to make it work so that it looks good is to hide it behind the shirt, since the reversed cable looks really weird in video. And when we do that, we start facing new problems – slight movements and shirt rubbing against the mike create noise. Is there a solution to this problem? If the mike is outside, it looks really bad in video (I have never seen anyone with their lav upside down in a professional video).

Phantom power might be an option for studios, but it does not work for us, since we travel a lot and do not want to be dealing with power requirements in the field.

0
Reply
Ludwig Keck
Ludwig Keck
May 18, 2016 3:20 pm

I got the impression that you mounted the mikes too high and maybe even too far to the side. Shotgun mikes work best when pointed at the speaker’s face from a location above and close to the camera to get the direct sound from the person speaking. Too high up and you have the mike “looking” at the ground or some place other than the speakers face.

0
Reply
Nasim Mansurov
Nasim Mansurov
Author
Reply to  Ludwig Keck
May 18, 2016 7:55 pm

Ludwig, we mounted the mike right above John’s head, so the proximity was not the issue. We did mount the mike a bit to the side due to the fact that we need the sound to be picked up both when the speaker is facing the camera and when facing the computer.

0
Reply
Ludwig Keck
Ludwig Keck
Reply to  Nasim Mansurov
May 18, 2016 9:05 pm

If you think of the speakers lips as the object to be photographed and the shotgun mike as a camera with a long lens, then you will position the mike much better than if you just see the mike as a sound receiver. Try it. [ I have used mikes poorly some sixty years ago. Gotten much better since then. ]

0
Reply
Nasim Mansurov
Nasim Mansurov
Author
Reply to  Ludwig Keck
May 19, 2016 8:58 am

Ludwig, thank you so much for your input, I really appreciate it! You seem to know about sound much more than we do, so your help is truly appreciated. We played with the shotgun setup before mounting it a bit to the right of John’s face and you are right – pointing it straight at the face did produce much better sound. If John only faced the front, having a setup like you’ve described would certainly work the best. However, for the video that we are shooting, it was important to capture even audio both when John was facing the camera and when he was facing the computer to his left (video right). For that, the ideal setup was to put it a bit off the side and point it at his head. After we did that, whether he looked directly at the camera or at the computer when turning, the audio sounded very even and nice. I am sure we could have gotten better audio with the front arrangement, but it would not have worked for us.

0
Reply
sceptical1
sceptical1
Reply to  Ludwig Keck
May 20, 2016 5:19 pm

Ludwig,
Thanks for this reply (also thank Andrew) With sound I am only doing EVERYTHING wrong. Sigh. More stuff to learn!

0
Reply
Ludwig Keck
Ludwig Keck
Reply to  sceptical1
May 20, 2016 6:10 pm

For a long time my favorite lament has been “Why does everything have to be a learning experience?!” But, such it is …

0
Reply
Tim Shoebridge
Tim Shoebridge
May 18, 2016 12:57 pm

Very nice review. Not sure if it was just my ears / sound equipment on playback but the Sennheiser seemed to pick up quite a bit more ambient noise than the other mics, by this I mean there seemed to be some room ambiance (reverb) that you can hear compared with the others. Not so sure therefore how it will work in an outdoor situation….?

0
Reply
Nasim Mansurov
Nasim Mansurov
Author
Reply to  Tim Shoebridge
May 18, 2016 7:54 pm

Tim, we felt like the Sennheiser gave us the most natural sound. We were not trying to just get speaker voice and nothing else in the room, since we are still shooting in an indoor environment and we want to pass that feeling of the indoor environment to the viewer. The others did not feel like they were giving us better sound quality than a lavalier mic from that standpoint. The Rode NTG3 had amazing sound, but it is just not a practical shotgun to use due to the power requirements. The Sennheiser does a pretty good job at isolating the sound too – we have tested the speaker moving around and it performed well overall. And lastly, the output level of the Sennheiser was very good, while the other two pretty much require external power to get to good sound levels.

0
Reply
sceptical1
sceptical1
May 18, 2016 11:43 am

Hi Nasim,
Timely post, almost magic. I am looking for a shotgun mike for doing story slideshows. I am having almost the exact same issues with my lav mike. I will get the Stenheiser and use my typical rechargeable Eneloop batteries so I can work for days in the field without worry.

0
Reply
Nasim Mansurov
Nasim Mansurov
Author
Reply to  sceptical1
May 18, 2016 7:48 pm

Sceptical, that’s exactly what we are using – Eneloop rechargeable batteries with the Sennheiser. The MKE 600 can operate up to 150 hours on a single charge, which is very nice.

0
Reply

Learn

  • Beginner Photography
  • Landscape Photography
  • Wildlife Photography
  • Portraiture
  • Post-Processing
  • Advanced Tutorials
Photography Life on Patreon

Reviews

  • Camera Reviews
  • Lens Reviews
  • Other Gear Reviews
  • Best Cameras and Lenses

Photography Tutorials

Photography Basics
Landscape Photography
Wildlife Photography
Macro Photography
Composition & Creativity
Black & White Photography
Night Sky Photography
Portrait Photography
Street Photography
Photography Videos

Unique Gift Ideas

Best Gifts for Photographers

Subscribe via Email

If you like our content, you can subscribe to our newsletter to receive weekly email updates using the link below:

Subscribe to our newsletter

Site Menu

  • About Us
  • Beginner Photography
  • Lens Database
  • Lens Index
  • Photo Spots
  • Search
  • Forum

Reviews

  • Reviews Archive
  • Camera Reviews
  • Lens Reviews
  • Other Gear Reviews

More

  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe
  • Workshops
  • Support Us
  • Submit Content

Copyright © 2025 · Photography Life

You are going to send email to

Move Comment