With so many editing / post-processing software packages on the market today, photographers might find it rather difficult to go through them all and compare key features in order to pick something that would ultimately work for their needs. Many of us go through that stage, especially when starting out. What is the best software for photo editing? What features does it have? Is it easy to learn and how much does it cost? These are just some of the questions photographers seek answers for. We decided to put together a detailed table that compares the most popular non-destructive editing tools on the market today.
We picked the following six software packages that offer non-destructive editing based on their popularity among photographers:
- Adobe Lightroom Classic CC
- Capture One Pro
- ACDSee Photo Studio
- On1 Photo RAW
- DxO PhotoLab
We recognize that there are many more out there, but we cannot include them all, since such research would take a lot more time and the chart would get massive, making it hard to read. If you disagree with our choices and would like to see other non-destructive software included, please let us know in the comments section below (note that destructive software editing tools such as Adobe Photoshop, Elements, Affinity Photo, PaintShop Pro and GIMP should not be in this list). To come up with all the data below, we had to install every software package on a single machine and run them all for some time, going through and testing out the features. It was a pretty exhausting task to say the least! Below is the software comparison table:
|Feature||Lightroom Classic||Capture One Pro||ACDSee PS||On1 Photo RAW||DxO PhotoLab||Luminar|
|1Subjective opinion based on personal experience of the author|
2HDR Merge Tool in ACDSee Photo Studio Ultimate 2020 is extremely poor / unusable
3Aurora HDR Tool must be purchased separately
|RAW File Support||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Fuji X-Trans RAW Support||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||No||Yes|
|4K+ / Retina Screen Support||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Dual Monitor Support||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||No||No|
|Basic RAW File Editing (Crop, Exposure, WB, etc)||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Templates / Presets||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Selective Noise Reduction||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Advanced Color Adjustments||No||Yes||No||No||Yes||No|
|Distortion, CA and Vignetting Corrections||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Merge to HDR||Yes||No||Yes2||Yes||No||No3|
|Merge to Panorama||Yes||No||No||Yes||No||No|
|Photoshop / Lightroom Integration||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Brushes / Masking||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Luminosity Masking||Yes||Yes||No||Yes||No||Yes||Spot / Dust Removal||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Insert New Objects||No||No||No||No||No||Yes|
|Speed / Performance1||4/5||4/5||5/5||3/5||3/5||3/5|
|Retail Price (MSRP)||N/A||$299||$149||$50||$199||$89|
|Cloud Subscription Price||$10/mo (+PS)||$24/mo||$69/yr (+extras)||$60/yr (+extras)||N/A||N/A|
|Device Activation Limit||2||3||1||5||3||2|
Please note that we did not list every possible feature and slider offered by each individual software package, as it would make the above chart unreadable. Instead, we decided to focus on the key / most important features and include additional data for consideration, such as Stability, Performance, Learning Curve and Update Frequency. Some of this data such as Stability and Learning Curve is rather subjective – it is based on my experience running the software, which might differ from other people’s experiences. So if you disagree, please let us know in the comments section below!
Based on the above chart, it is pretty clear that most modern image editing tools tightly compete with each other. If just a few years back Lightroom and Capture One were in the lead, other software such as On1 Photo RAW and Lumunar caught up with a lot of the features, including Digital Asset Management (DAM) for the proper file management.
Personally, I primarily use Lightroom Classic CC for my editing needs, but every once in a while, I fire up Capture One Pro to do some editing. While some of the features that Capture One Pro offers are light years ahead of Lightroom (advanced color adjustments, layers, masking, tethering, etc), its file management features / DAM are rather weak, and it is not an easy tool to get used to. In addition, it has no capabilities to merge HDRs and Panoramas, which is the strength of Lightroom when compared to everything else out there.
ACDSee Photo Studio Ultimate is great for those who are starting out, and its extensive list of features is impressive. However, ACDsee is quite buggy, has very annoying notifications that cannot be easily turned off, and its license limit of 1 is very limiting for those who own more than one machine. I used to rely on ACDSee for viewing images before, but it has gotten slower over time, and ever since I started using FastRawViewer for image culling, I see no need for it anymore.
DxO PhotoLab feels a bit out of place here, since it is designed to be more of a plugin for Lightroom and not its direct competitor. However, considering how well its lens corrections tools work, it is certainly worth having a look at. Since purchasing Nik Software, DxO added the U Point technology into PhotoLab, which works amazingly well for quick and easy adjustments. Best of all, it is very easy to use, and its default rendering of RAW images is excellent. The biggest issue with DxO PhotoLab for me personally, and the reason why I stopped using it, is the lack of Fuji X-Trans RAW support. I personally use Fuji X-series cameras a lot, and find it unacceptable that DxO is continuing to refuse to add support for Fuji X-Trans.
On1 Photo RAW and Luminar have evolved quite a bit in the past few years, going from a very limited feature-set to a full-blown solution that competes head-to-head with Lightroom and Capture One. I must admit, I have limited experience with both of these tools when compared to Lightroom and Capture One, so I am planning to spend a bit more time with them to see which one I like better. So far, Luminar looks a bit more attractive to me due to its versatility and easy to use interface, but On1 also has its strengths (the image resize / enlargement tool is excellent). I found both to be a bit sluggish and occasionally buggy though, which is unfortunate.
What software do you use for post-processing and what do you like / dislike about it? Please let me know in the comments section below!